Yahwist and Priestly Versions of the Plagues: 7 vs. 10

The Yahwist narrative supplied eight plagues. The plagues of gnats and boils were added to the original series by the Priestly editor who was responsible for the final edition. Priestly additions are marked in purple.

Yahwist

Completed Priestly Edition

1. Water to blood 7:14-18, 20b-21a

1. Water to blood 7:19-20a, 21b-22

2. Frogs 7:25, 8:1-4, 8-15

2. Frogs 8:5-7

 

3. Gnats 8:16-19

3. Flies 8:20-32

4. Flies (J)

4. Cattle plague 9:1-7

5. Cattle plague (J)

 

6. Boils on humans and animals 9:8-12

5. Hail 9:13-35

7. Hail (J)

6. Locusts 10:1-20

8. Locusts (J)

7. Darkness 10:21-29

9. Darkness (J)

8. Death of firstborn 11:1-8

10. Death of firstborn (J)

 

 

  Literary Structure of the Plague Narrative

Series

Plague

Exodus

Forewarning

Time

Instruction

Agent

Hardening

 

Sign

7:1-13

 

 

"Say to Aaron, Take your rod"

Aaron

"Pharaoh's heart was hardened"

First

1. Nile to blood

7:14-24

yes

morning

"Go to Pharaoh in the morning"

Aaron

"Pharaoh's heart was hardened"

 

2. Frogs

7:25-8:15

yes

 

"Go in to Pharaoh"

Aaron

"Pharaoh hardened his heart"

 

3. Gnats

8:16-19

 

 

"Say to Aaron, Stretch your rod"

Aaron

"Pharaoh's heart was hardened"

Second

4. Flies

8:20-32

yes

morning

"Rise up early in the morning and wait for Pharaoh"

God

"Pharaoh hardened his heart"

 

5. Cattle plague

9:1-7

yes

 

"Go in to Pharaoh"

God

"Pharaoh's heart was hardened"

 

6. Boils

9:8-12

 

 

"Take handfuls of ashes"

Moses

"Yahweh hardened the heart of Pharaoh"

Third

7. Hail

9:13-35

yes

morning

"Rise up early in the morning and stand before Pharaoh"

Moses

"Pharaoh's heart was hardened"

 

8. Locusts

10:1-20

yes

 

"Go in to Pharaoh"

Moses

"Yahweh hardened Pharaoh's heart"

 

9. Darkness

10:21-29

 

 

"Stretch out your hand"

Moses

"Yahweh hardened Pharaoh's heart"

Climax

10. Death of Firstborn

11:1-10

yes

 

 

God

"Yahweh hardened Pharaoh's heart"

Notice the literary symmetry of the plagues narrative. The plagues are ordered into three series of three disasters each. The tenth plague stands alone and is the climax. The symmetrical structure is established by repetitions within the narrative. Notice that a time indication is provided only for the first, fourth, and seventh plagues. No forewarning is given for the third, sixth, and ninth plagues. There is also a pattern to the instructions given to Moses.

Examine the literary symmetry and ponder its literary and theological significance. Though the plagues narrative was composed using Yahwist and Priestly source material, the final narrative is well-formed. Does the structural symmetry also suggest that these disasters, while perhaps having natural explanation, are also purposeful and divinely directed?